Employee turnover costs U.S. businesses $1.1 trillion yearly, a figure that dwarfs the GDP of most countries. However, more than 70% of employees who quit cite preventable reasons like burnout, lack of support, or unmanageable workloads. The solution? A stronger, more strategic focus on mental health.
Mounting evidence shows that companies that prioritize mental health outperform peers in both retention and resilience. This is the future of better, more productive workplaces.
Let’s take a closer look at how MLW-certified leaders like Cloudflare, Thryv, and Southern Veterinary Partners have been able to reduce turnover by up to 30%. Their primary focus: mental health strategies.
The High Cost of Ignoring Mental Health
Consider a scenario where you end up losing a ~1/4th of your workforce every year. Unfortunately, for many tech and healthcare firms, this isn’t hypothetical, it’s reality. The Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) estimates that replacing a single employee costs 6–9 months of their salary, draining resources and destabilizing teams. But attrition’s true toll is cultural: eroded trust, disrupted projects, and a lingering fear of “who’s next.”
But why do mental health programs curb turnover? Generally, it is well-observed that employees who feel supported are 3.2x more likely to stay (Boston College, 2024). Studies further show that resilient teams adapt faster to crises, reducing panic-driven exits; something that has been noticed quite fervently since COVID-19. This has led to a very critical conclusion for many; mental health needs to be more than a perk, but instead has become a retention lifeline.
Case Study 1: Cloudflare’s “Mental Health First” Revolution
Source: Cloudflare 2023 Impact Report
In 2021, Cloudflare, an MLW Certified Workplace, faced a crisis: 28% of its engineers left yearly, citing unsustainable workloads and burnout. For this, Cloudflare launched a “Mental Health First” policy with three pillars:
- Unlimited Mental Health Days: Employees take paid time off without explanation, no questions asked.
- Real-Time Stress Sensors: Managers use anonymized data from wellness apps like Calm to spot burnout trends.
- Therapy Stipends: $5,000/year for counseling, coaching, or mindfulness programs.
The results stunned leadership. By 2023, engineering turnover plummeted to 6%, below industry averages, while 89% of employees reported feeling “supported during personal crises.”
“Mental health isn’t a checkbox, it’s core to how we innovate,” says Cloudflare COO Michelle Zatlyn. Teams now complete projects 15% faster, proving that psychological safety fuels productivity.
Want to build a workplace where well-being drives performance? Apply for the Best Practice Awards and gain national recognition for your mental health and retention strategies that set a new standard in leadership.
Case Study 2: Thryv’s Flexible Work Experiment
Source: Thryv 2023 Workplace Report
Thryv lost 18% of its customer support staff in 2022 due to rigid schedules clashing with caregiving and health needs. Thryv introduced a “Flexible Fridays” policy to curb this, which included:
- No Meetings, No Deadlines: Fridays became a meeting-free zone for rest, skill-building, or personal projects.
- Resilience Training: Managers took BPI-certified courses on spotting burnout signs like withdrawal or irritability.
- Peer Support Networks: Monthly “mental health circles” let employees share struggles without judgment.
The policy is optional, allowing employees to structure their Fridays based on their needs. Within a year, voluntary turnover dropped by one-third, and customer satisfaction scores rose 19%.
A study by Gartner found that flexible work arrangements reduce stress by improving psychological safety and autonomy. Harvard Business Review also noted that autonomy drives engagement and performance.
Case Study 3: Southern Veterinary Partners’ Compassionate Care Model
Source: SVP 2023 Press Release
Veterinary medicine in general faces a massive 52% burnout rate, and Southern Veterinary Partners (SVP) saw this in 2022. This was because of grief over patient loss and emotional exhaustion. Their response included a three-tiered support system, which involved:
- Mental Health Sabbaticals: Two weeks of paid leave for employees coping with burnout or trauma.
- Onsite Counselors: Clinics partnered with therapists for free, confidential sessions during shifts.
- Grief Training: Staff learned to process patient deaths without guilt through workshops.
By 2023, turnover sank to 12%, while 94% of employees called SVP “a supportive workplace,” up from 67%. “We stopped asking people to ‘tough it out,’” says one of the managers. “Now they stay because they feel seen.”
The transition was clear: grief support directly reduced turnover by fostering emotional resilience. Studies show that workplaces that actively support grieving employees see higher morale, stronger retention, and improved productivity.
Science-Backed Strategies to Reduce Turnover
Beyond these proven case studies, additional science-backed strategies have emerged to help organizations retain top talent.
1. Normalize Mental Health Conversations
42% of employees fear discussing mental health will harm their careers. MLW-certified JobNimbus managed to shatter this stigma quite well thanks to its weekly webinars, where leaders shared their struggles with anxiety and depression. It saw a significant spike in EAP usage and a 25% lower turnover in 2023.
Your Move: Train managers to ask, “How are you really doing?” in 1:1s. Role-play responses to disclosures so they avoid toxic positivity like “Stay strong!”
2. Link Mental Health to Career Growth
Employees who tie well-being to career success are 2.6x more likely to stay (Gallup, 2021). ExtensisHR, an MLW-certified payroll firm, redesigned promotions to reward leaders who improve team morale and model self-care. One manager earned a raise after slashing her team’s overtime by 45% through workload audits.
Your Move: Add “empathy” and “resilience” to competency frameworks. Track how managers balance productivity with well-being.
3. Audit Workloads Ruthlessly
Unrealistic workloads drive a majority of resignations. Springfield Clinic, a healthcare network, adopted BPI’s Workload Balance Scorecard approach to flag teams nearing burnout. When metrics hit “overload” thresholds, tasks are redistributed automatically. Turnover fell significantly in six months.
Your Move: Pilot a four-day workweek with one team. Measure output, not hours, BPI data shows most teams maintain productivity.
Why Most Mental Health Programs Fail
Many companies make three fatal mistakes when it comes to their mental health programs:
1. One-Size-Fits-All Solutions
Generic yoga classes or meditation apps ignore industry-specific stressors. Veterinary teams need grief support; engineers need meeting-free coding blocks.
2. Untrained Managers
Without coaching, managers default to “Are you OK?” checkboxes. BPI’s Resilient Leadership Program teaches actionable skills like workload auditing and empathetic feedback.
3. No ROI Tracking
Leaders scrap programs during cuts if they can’t prove impact. MLW-certified firms tie mental health metrics to turnover, productivity, and customer satisfaction.
Your Next Step: Become BPI-Certified
BPI’s Leadership Development Resources equips leaders with tools to build low-turnover workplaces:
- Benchmarking: Compare policies against 500+ certified companies like Cloudflare.
- Custom Playbooks: Fix gaps in 90 days with step-by-step guides for your industry.
- Turnover Risk Assessments: Predict attrition hotspots using predictive analytics.
Turnover may seem inevitable, but in reality, it is more of a choice. A choice to prioritize spreadsheets over people, speed over sustainability. Companies like Thryv, SVP, and many others prove time and again that mental health investments go well beyond just another expense for your company. Instead, they can become the very foundation of loyalty, innovation, and grit from your employees toward you.
One HR leader noted, “Certification gave us the framework to support employees holistically. Retention improved, and engagement soared.” Remember, people stay because companies treat them as a human, not a resource.
Be recognized for the workplace culture you’ve built. The Best Practice Awards honor companies that treat mental health as a foundation for performance.
.
